Bilaam and Change

Midrash, Bamidbar Rabbah asks:

“Why don’t animals speak?”

“If they were able to speak it would be impossible for them to work for humans and no one could stand against them.  For here is this donkey, the most stupid of all creatures, and then there was her master, Balaam, the wisest of all men, and he could not contend with the donkey.”

“Therefore out of consideration for people, the Holy One closed the mouths of beasts.”

Remember the last time an animal spoke in the Torah?  It was in the Garden of Eden.  And that event was so cataclysmic it ended with the first man women disabusing one another ending with their expulsion from Eden.  It all started with a talking snake. 

Such a comment gels with the Torah, which states that “God opened the mouth of the donkey…” (Num. 22:28).  Until now, it was firmly shut along with all the other beasts of the world since the time of Eden. 

According to one Hasidic source, the nations of the world hear that Moshe rabbenu has led the forces of Israel from bondage and through glorious conquests since their liberation.  They further murmured that Moshe’s strength was inimical to him: His speech abilities enabled the Israelites to vanquish all their enemies.  That is why God disproved them by placing the power of speech in the donkey’s mouth.  This would prove the power of God was the source of all true power (imrei kohen)

The donkey also has a past.  According to Midrash he was a gift given by Jacob to pharaoh.  You will remember how Jacob spent his final years in Egypt, brought by his son Joseph, viceroy to the throne.

Jacob gifted the donkey to the Pharaoh with the caveat that the king always treats the Israelites kindly.  Time passed and Bilaam, the prophet-for-hire, bent the ear of the Pharaoh and convinced him that Pharaoh could make better use of the Jews by making them work for him, eventually enslaving them. Bilaam further advised Pharaoh to increase the quota of bricks that the Jews were forced to make.

It is interesting what the Midrash is doing. The Midrash is trying to sew the thread between various stories so that we can get a bigger picture of these narratives.  Everything is connected.  Bilaam’s noxious behavior is consistent throughout the years.  He can spotted throughout the ages advising people on how best to hurt one another.

Do people change?  Of course they do but it does not come easily or without effort.  Most times, the effort comes from elsewhere, from the unconsidered aspects of life.  There often needs to be an “emergency” or an unavoidable conflict that forces us to bend. In Bilaam’s instance change does not come until God decides that He will intervene. 

That is where the donkey comes in.  Apparently, Bilaam refuses change until he hears it from an unlikely source, one that has remained silent since Eden.

Balak: The Force?

Underlying the text are some powerful messages that lurk just beneath the veneer of the words. One of them is the imagery of the sword. The first time in the story where a sword appears is in the hands of the angel that stands in the way of Bilaam. A donkey, frightened by the vision of the angel with the sword, veers off course and finally refuses to budge.

It is highly evocative and frankly bizarre that the Torah depicts a non-Jewish prophet, Bilaam, going out to curse the Israelite nation. On the way God sent an angel to impede the way of Bilaam. The angel wards off the donkey that the prophet rides on. Bilaam, unaware of the presence of the angel, continues to urge the animal forward. When Bilaam ultimately realizes that God has dispatched an emissary to stop him he confesses that he has sinned.

Yet, there is a problem with the text: how could Bilaam have sinned when he did not see that his way was being blocked? Can he really be blamed for sinning when he did not know the angel was there?

This was precisely the sin. Bilaam erred because he did not see the messenger of the Lord. He should have realized that there was an angel there but he was so preoccupied by his own thoughts that Bilaam was basically blind. How can this be? Being a person of vision is what a prophet does. He is supposed to see what others cannot! That is why the Torah states, Then the Lord opened the eyes of Balaam, and he saw the angel of the Lord standing in the way, and his sword drawn in his hand: and he bowed down his head, and fell on his face.

Compare this episode to the one in Genesis where Abraham marches with his servants and son to the appointed place of the Sacrifice. When they arrive at Moriah only the father and son are able to recognize it. The servants, and the donkey!, see nothing. 1 This is the way of the real man of God. He sees. Making matters worse for Bilaam, he had already identified himself as a prophet of God. Surely then his inability to see the holy emissary of the Lord is at best evidence of a lapse in his seer-hood, at worst exposes him as a fraud.

Is this the sin of Bilaam? Early in the reading Bilaam is identified as a man whose blessings and curses becomes reality. At least that is what the king Balak believes and says. When Bilaam appeals to God for guidance he is told that the people of Israel are blessed and that he must not place a curse on them. What does this prophet then do? He mounts his donkey to level a curse at the Israelites! He even has the chutzpah to tell the king that he is not motivated by all the gold and silver in the treasury. Then why does he go? The only reasonable conclusions would be pure hatred, megalomania – Bilaam was in love with himself – or he was not a real prophet after all.

The Mishna makes its choice. It states, "Whoever has three particular traits is counted among the students of Abraham, and whoever has three other traits is among the students of Bilaam. He who has a good eye, humility and contentedness is a student of Abraham, while he who has an evil eye, arrogance and greed is a student of Bilaam." 2

This teaching would indicate megalomania on the part of Bilaam. He was consumed with his own power and prestige. He only saw what he was predisposed to see, i.e. anything that would advance his self-interest. Yet, how is it possible that even a self- consumed person would brazenly reject the spoken Word of God?

Looking at the tale carefully there is another problem. Torah tells that the elders of Moab and Midian approached Bilaam conveying the demand of King Balak. Bilaam replied they should wait until the morning because he first needed to consult with God. The next morning Bilaam gave his answer to the officials of King Balak. Wait! What happened to the elders of Midian and Moab?

The Talmud 3 tells that as soon as the elders of Midian and Moab heard that Bilaam was going to consult God, they went home. They said: "No father hates his son." These high ranking emissaries knew about the relationship between the Jews and God. They understood their cause was lost. Again we are confronted with the question, what was wrong with Bilaam that everyone, including his donkey, seems to know but not him?

The end of the tale of course is that Bilaam, against his will, blesses the Israelites three times. Afterward, however, Bilaam dies by the sword. Was it the same sword that the angel held when he stopped the donkey?

In the final analysis it is impossible to know what motivates a person to do what they do. What matters is what a person does. Like Bilaam, Hitler never personally murdered anyone. Yet his words brought millions to agonizing torture and death. Perhaps then this is the real lesson of the Torah: Be concerned with the import of what we say. It could lead to terrible consequences. An evil word maybe the equivalent of a steel blade. And when God speaks, listen.



1 Rashi Genesis 22:4-5
2 Pirkei Avot 5:22
3 Sanhedrin 105


Haftara Insight:
The "Remnant of Jacob" is community of faithful that have been loyal and are the linkage which connect the generations. The promise to Abraham has been kept. We are here.
The words of Micah conclude with a stirring and powerful message. It is the answer to the question: What does God want in return? "….He has told you, O man, what is good, and what the Lord demands of you; but to do justice, to love loving-kindness, and to walk discreetly with your God. "

A Matter of Law:
The halacha to maintain only intimate relations with Jews is in this reading. As Bilaam makes fun of this nation we learn that mockery is unacceptable. Disagreements need to be kept serious and not reduced to personal attack. Finally, respect all people as even a mercenary like Bilaam can sometimes be privy to the Word of God.